/, events, media attention/Singapore vs Hong Kong

Singapore vs Hong Kong

To Singapore, where Southeast Asia’s largest bookshop — Kinokuniya on Orchard Road — has agreed to host a book signing event with Alain Robert. The French wall-climber, author of With Bare Hands, is in town for a few days and we’ve taken the chance to line up some interviews with Singaporean newspapers and Mediacorp radio.

Despite having lived in the region for 16 years, it’s my first time in the Lion City, and I’m interested to see how it compares with Hong Kong. The two cities are rivals, especially in business. On the surface they seem similar: small, developed city-states with majority Chinese populations and economies based on trade. But I soon find that there are many differences too: Singapore’s town planning knocks Hong Kong out of the water (it’s a much more pleasant city to walk around), and its preservation and re-use of historic buildings is a great achievement. We’re often told that Hong Kong’s lack of land is the driving factor behind the demolition of all our built heritage, but it’s clear that government policy has played its part too. Singapore has less land than Hong Kong but they have managed very well. Of course an authoritarian government with unlimited powers to mould the cityscape has helped; this is another stark difference between the two.

The relative cheapness of land in Singapore translates to more floor space for retail, and the city’s bookshops are correspondingly larger than their Hong Kong counterparts. The Kinokuniya flagship store has computer terminals at its four corners to help you locate books; it would simply take too long to browse the shelves otherwise. And there’s an area in the centre of the store set aside for book signings.

Other book chains such as Borders and MPH have equally large branches, but one smaller shop I found is also worth a mention: Select Books in the Tanglin shopping centre specializes in Asian books of all kinds.

2017-11-05T20:41:10+00:00February 13th, 2009|authors, events, media attention|4 Comments


  1. cath April 1, 2009 at 12:17 am - Reply

    Hi Pete,

    I came across your blog through an email from a writing circle. I’m glad you mentioned Select Books. It’s one of the very few small and good book stores left here, tucked away in a forgotten shopping centre in Singapore.

    Your publishing house sounds really interesting. Maybe someday when I get around to writing my “family stories”, I can send it to you for a look.

    Meanwhile, I wish you success and hope that there will come a time when you won’t need to take “forever” to get back to your writers. 🙂

    All the best,

  2. Pete April 1, 2009 at 5:37 pm - Reply

    Thanks for visiting, Catherine. At the moment, ‘forever’ is between 3 weeks and 3 months… although we’re getting quicker, so are the writers!

  3. Tony September 29, 2009 at 5:36 pm - Reply

    To be fair, although Hong Kong is twice as big as Singapore in theory, it is not as flat a pancake as Singapore. In fact, it is so hilly that around 60-70% of the land has been declared as countrypark, whereas some 7 million people are crammed into the remaining land.

  4. doggydog June 11, 2010 at 5:19 pm - Reply

    I won’t say twice as big. Hong Kong is maybe 1 1/2 times the size of Singapore but as Tony said, over 70% of Hong Kong’s land is mountainous, while Singapore is almost entirely flat. Therefore, while Singapore is almost completely urbanised, Hong Kong is mostly rural, and the majority of Hong Kong’s 7 million people (more than Singapore’s 5 million) is crammed into a very small area. In fact, if you subtract the mountainous areas, Hong Kong’s buildable land area is actually less than Singapore, which makes it appear more crowded.

Leave a reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.